Bringing Compensation to Victims
Recent Results
Home | Results
Mass Tort
$
0
M
Cases in Settlement
Mass Tort
$
0
M
Settled Cases
Environmental Law
$
0
M
Toxic Tort
Medical Device Case
Settlement Total: $88 Million
- Date: Verdict returned August 4, 2026
Larry Patterson received a Covidien Symbotex hernia mesh implant in 2017. His case was the first bellwether trial to go before a jury out of roughly 10,350 plaintiffs nationally pursuing claims against Medtronic over its Parietex, ProGrip, and Symbotex hernia mesh lines.
The mesh’s absorbable collagen barrier dissolved far faster than represented, causing the underlying polyester mesh to adhere to his bowel and leading to a bowel obstruction requiring major surgery, including a bowel resection.
This verdict resolves only the Pattersons’ claims; it does not directly decide or aggregate outcomes for other plaintiffs, though it’s expected to influence how the remaining cases are valued and negotiated going forward.
Public Source: U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, Patterson v. Covidien, Inc., No. 1:22-cv-10153-PBS (MDL No. 3029) — case docket
*Past results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case.
-
Case: Patterson v. Covidien, Inc., No. 22-cv-10153-PBS (In re: Covidien Hernia Mesh Products Liability Litigation, MDL No. 3029)
-
Court: U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts (Boston)
-
Judge: Hon. Patti B. Saris
-
Responsible Attorney: Andrea Giovannone (Rueb, Stoller & Daniel, LLP) — involved with expert witnesses and trial preparation
-
Verdict: $88 million total — $77 million compensatory to Larry Patterson, $11 million to Tammy Patterson for loss of consortium. No punitive damages; jury did not find fraud.
-
Firm Role: Co-counsel / trial team member. Trial was led by Timothy M. O’Brien (Levin, Papantonio, Proctor, Buchanan, O’Brien, Barr & Mougey), with Kelsey Stokes (Stokes & Hobbs) handling key witnesses. Four firms held leadership roles: RSD, Levin Papantonio, Stokes & Hobbs, and Nigh Goldenberg Raso & Vaughn.
-
Number of Clients: 1 (Larry and Tammy Patterson)
-
Result Type: Individual client outcome — this is the first bellwether trial out of 10,000+ Covidien hernia mesh cases nationally.
Medical Malpractice Win
Settlement Total: $2,549,999
- Date: December 4, 2025
After nearly eight hours of second-stage labor with a deteriorating fetal heart rate strip, the OB/GYN opted for a vacuum-assisted delivery rather than an emergent C-section. The delivery involved a prolonged, complicated shoulder dystocia. The infant suffered severe neonatal encephalopathy and died roughly three hours after birth; an autopsy attributed the cause of death to metabolic acidosis from the prolonged delivery. The mother sustained a rectovaginal fistula from the vacuum extraction, leading to permanent fecal incontinence after an unsuccessful surgical repair.
Plaintiffs alleged the physician breached the standard of care by delaying cesarean delivery and over-extending vacuum use, and that hospital nursing staff failed to escalate fetal monitoring concerns and administered Pitocin despite contraindication.
Public Source: Judicate West mediation summary (private mediation — not a court filing of public record; sourced from published settlement-reporter summary, not PACER/court docket)
*Past results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case.
-
Case: Doe Plaintiffs v. Roe OB/GYN, Roe Group, Roe Hospital (anonymized — obstetric malpractice / wrongful death)
-
Forum: Judicate West (mediation)
-
Responsible Attorney: Amorina E. Lopez, Rueb, Stoller & Daniel, LLP
-
Settlement Total: $2,549,999 — Roe OB/GYN paid $999,999 (full policy limits tendered; liability not contested), Roe Group paid $800,000 (vicarious liability), and Roe Hospital paid $750,000.
-
Firm Role: Plaintiff’s counsel
-
Mediator: Jay C. Horton
-
Number of Clients: 2 (mother, and infant’s estate)
-
Result Type: Individual client outcome — not an aggregate program or inventory-wide resolution
IMPORTANT CASE RESULTS DISCLAIMER:
Past results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case. Every case is unique and must be evaluated on its own individual merits. The results shown represent settlements or verdicts obtained in specific cases and do not constitute a promise, guarantee, or prediction of the outcome of any other case. Case results depend on a variety of factors unique to each case.
$275 Million
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Global Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Individual Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Inventory Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Partial Inventory Consumer Product Settlement
Practice Area: Pharmaceutical
Description: Inventory Pharmaceutical Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Inventory Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Inventory Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Partial Inventory Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Inventory Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Inventory Medical Device Settlement
Practice Area: Medical Device
Description: Partial Inventory Medical Device Settlement